Out of Sight, Out of Mind: What My Missing Pen Taught Me About Our Brains and Clutter
I have a confession to make: I am a bit of a pen snob.
For the last three years, my favorite pen has been a pink Flexion 0.5 pen with four ink colors and an eraser. It feels good on paper, makes my handwriting neater, and I can switch colors whenever I get bored. When I lost my original pen in Japan, I bought the exact same one. I know. It's a little nerdy.
It is clear that I love this pen. I cared enough about it to replace it when I lost it. Yet, I didn't notice it was missing from my world for at least four months, until today. It was kept inside my brown leather pencil case. That discovery got me thinking: Can something be important to us without being mentally available?
Visual Cues…
We often use the phrase “out of sight, out of mind” as if it simply means we're forgetful, but for many of my clients with ADHD, I think there is something more interesting going on.
I often hear my clients say, “If I put it away, I'll forget about it,” or “I need to keep this out where I can see it, or I'll forget that I need to deal with it.” And there is some logic to that.
Our brains use environmental cues all the time. A mail on the kitchen counter can remind us to pay a bill. A library book by the front door reminds us to return it. A pile of clothes on the chair reminds us that we still need to fold the laundry. Our brains are remarkably responsive to visual information, and we use what we see around us as cues for what needs our attention.
For people with ADHD, relying on those visual and external cues may be especially important because working memory and prospective memory—the ability to hold information temporarily and remember to do something later—can be challenging. So a pile isn’t always simply a sign of disorganization.
Sometimes the pile is the reminder.
The problem is that the reminder comes with a cost. Every time you walk past the pile, your brain gets another message: “Don't forget this.” “You were supposed to take care of this a month ago.” “When are you going to take care of this?” Soon, the entire room can feel like one giant to-do list.
Do you remember how your pile gets started? Imagine you receive an important document while you're in the middle of making dinner. You know you need to do something with it. But you don't have the time—or the mental bandwidth—to figure out exactly what. If you put it away somewhere, you're afraid you'll forget it exists. So you put it on the counter. That solves one problem: You won't forget about it.
But now you've created another: The counter becomes the place where unfinished thoughts go to wait. Over time, one document becomes five. Five become a stack. “And eventually, you have a pile. But the pile isn’t necessarily the problem. It may be a solution that has gotten out of hand.
Working memory and prospective memory can be part of this cycle. When we're distracted or interrupted, it can be difficult to hold onto all the information needed to complete a multi-step task. By keeping objects in plain sight, we allow our surroundings to help us remember important tasks. In other words, the pile may be doing a job. It's just not a very peaceful job.
But what about my pen?
Here's where my missing pen made me think about this differently. I didn't consciously decide to forget about it. I didn't stop liking it or replace it because I preferred another pen. It simply disappeared from my visual world. And apparently, my brain didn't send me a notification saying, "Hey, where is that pink four-color eraser pen you really like?"
Nothing. For four months. Then today, something triggered the search. A few of my pens were running out of ink, and I was looking for another one. That may have reminded me of the pen I liked better. I thought I lost it again, which made me think about my trip to Japan. Then I remembered unpacking my bags.
A pen missing ink → Where is another pen that works? → What about my favorite pen? → Japan trip → pencil case → pen. Suddenly, there it was. My long-term memory hadn't failed me. I simply didn't have the right cue to retrieve that particular memory. I didn't even realize I still had it. I had to see it before it returned to my mental world. My brain's internal search index didn't seem to have a reason to run the search because there was no visual or contextual cue.
Another reason my pen stayed forgotten for so long may be that I had other pens that worked. They weren't my favorite, but they were good enough. Because my immediate need—to write something—was already being met, my brain didn't seem to have a strong reason to search for a better solution.
And I see something similar with my clients. They may own a favorite sweater, but several other sweaters are hanging in the closet. They may have a favorite kitchen tool, but three others work well enough. They may have a duplicate item stored in a box somewhere, while the version they use every day is sitting right in front of them.
The hidden item hasn't necessarily become meaningless. It's simply not part of our active daily life. This is one reason I find decluttering so fascinating. When we open an old box in a basement, garage, or closet, clients often say: “I can't believe we still had this!” Or “I completely forgot about this.” And sometimes what they find is something they genuinely love.
A beautifully preserved childhood coat.
A pair of favorite shoes from their twenties.
A photograph from their grandparents.
A quirky little object they once treasured.
They hadn't thought about it for years, yet when they see it again, the emotion comes rushing back. Out of sight didn't necessarily mean we stopped caring. Seeing it again can bring it back into our day-to-day lives.
What if we could use “out of sight, out of mind” to our advantage?
This is where I think the idea gets really interesting. Many people experience intense anxiety when they're trying to let go of things. They may know intellectually that they no longer use something. They may even agree that getting rid of it would make their life easier. But emotionally? “What if I need it someday?” can feel much louder than “I haven't used this in five years.” So instead of forcing an immediate Keep-or-Let-Go decision, what if we ran an experiment?
Try a Time-Capsule Box
Take the things you're struggling to let go of:
Duplicates
“Just in case” items
Things you haven't used in years
Things you're keeping because you might need them someday
Put them in a box and close it. Write a date on it six months or a year from now. Then put it somewhere you don't see it regularly. The goal isn't to trick yourself or prove you never needed those things. It's simply an experiment.
If you need something from the box, you can get it. If you don't think about anything in the box for six months, that's useful information too. You may discover that your life continued just fine without those items taking up physical space—and mental space. And perhaps the decision to let them go will feel very different then. This is especially important for people who struggle with chronic disorganization. Decluttering advice often sounds like:
Decide.
Be ruthless.
If you haven't used it in a year, get rid of it.
But our brains don't always make decisions in the same way. Sometimes the best way to make a difficult decision is to reduce the pressure around the decision. You don't have to throw something away today, but maybe create a little distance. You can gather information and see what happens. And sometimes, that information is surprisingly powerful.
Because if something has been out of sight for six months and you haven't remembered it once, looked for it, or needed it, you have learned something important, not necessarily that the item has no meaning. But perhaps that you don't need it in your life right now. And that's a different question.
And my pen?
I'm keeping it. Of course, I am. It's my favorite pen. But finding it also made me think about all the things I've let go of over the years that I haven't thought about since. I don't remember everything I've gotten rid of. And maybe that's the point. As we move through life, our circumstances change, our priorities change, and sometimes, our favorite things change, too.
We don't have to remember every object we own, and we don't have to keep everything important forever. And we don't have to fight “out of sight, out of mind” all the time. Sometimes, we can work with the way our brains naturally operate.
Maybe forgetting something isn't always a problem to solve. Sometimes, it's simply a sign that we're ready to make room for what matters now.





Comments