top of page
Search

Is It Hoarding? What Every Adult Child Should Know Before Trying to Help Aging Parents

About a month ago, a woman in her 50s called me about her mother.

"I don't know what to do," she said. "Every room is full, and it's such a mess. She doesn't see that as a problem.  She can’t even sleep in her own bed anymore."


Lately, I've been receiving several calls like this from adult children worried about their aging parents' homes. Although every story is different, the question is almost always the same:

"Is my parent a hoarder?"


It's an understandable question, but it's also one of the hardest to answer by phone. A house full of many years' belongings doesn't always mean someone has a hoarding disorder. 

The first step is to understand whether you're dealing with a normal accumulation, chronic disorganization, or a true hoarding disorder. They aren't the same thing, and approaching them the same way can actually make things worse.


Many older adults have lived in the same house for 30 or 40 years. Over the years, they've raised families, inherited things from loved ones, put off tough decisions, and gathered a lifetime of memories. So it's not surprising that homes can get crowded. But a house filled with decades of belongings doesn't necessarily mean hoarding. 

Mental health experts diagnose hoarding disorder using criteria outlined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5-TR). There are four key signs they look for:

  • Persistent difficulty discarding possessions, regardless of their actual value.

  • Ongoing acquisition of a large volume of items or a strong urge to save them.

  • Clutter that prevents rooms from being used for their intended purpose.

  • Significant distress or impairment caused by the clutter.


Clutter alone is not enough to diagnose hoarding disorder. There are many reasons a home becomes cluttered, including depression, grief, ADHD, executive functioning challenges, mobility limitations, aging, and self-neglect, including living in squalid conditions. Hoarding is about persistent difficulty discarding possessions and excessive attachment to them—not about cleanliness.


A person can have a relatively clean home and still struggle with a hoarding disorder. Likewise, someone can live in a dirty or squalid environment without having a hoarding disorder. Animal hoarding is a notable exception because sanitation often becomes a significant part of the problem.


I intentionally avoid referring to someone as "a hoarder." Hoarding is a mental health condition—not a person's identity. Just as we wouldn't define someone solely by diabetes or arthritis, we shouldn't define someone by a hoarding disorder. People are far more than the challenges they face.

When family members contact me about a parent's severe clutter, I begin by gathering information—not to diagnose, but to better understand the situation.


Some of the questions I ask include:

  • Tell me about the home.

  • Which rooms are still usable?

  • Are pathways and exits clear?

  • Is your parent still acquiring new things?

  • How long has this been happening?

  • Does your parent recognize the problem or want help?

  • Has your parent ever worked with a mental health professional?

  • Are there immediate safety concerns?

One question is especially important:

"Is your parent willing to accept help?" The answer shapes everything that follows.


As a professional organizer and coach, I can only help when someone is open to and ready for change. I can't make someone change if they aren't ready.


By the time families reach out to me, they usually aren't looking for decluttering tips—they’re hoping for a breakthrough. They want someone to help their parents recognize the problem, accept help, and start moving forward.


When I listen, I hear more than just concern for a parent’s safety. There’s often frustration, helplessness, and even desperation. Many families have pleaded, argued, offered to help, or threatened to "bring in a dumpster," but nothing seems to work.


Real and lasting change can only happen when the person is truly ready—no matter how much others want it for them.

So, if you can't force your parents to change, what can you do? You can start by changing your approach. Instead of making the conversation about the clutter, start by sharing your concerns about their safety and well-being.


Rather than saying, "Mom, you need to get rid of all this stuff," try saying, "Mom, I'm worried about your safety." Or ask, "Dad, how are you managing around the house?" The goal is not to win an argument about possessions. The goal is to open a conversation built on trust.

One resource I often recommend is Digging Out: Helping Your Loved One Manage Clutter, Hoarding & Compulsive Acquiring by Michael A. Tompkins and Tamara L. Hartl.


The book introduces a communication model called LEAP:

  • Listen

  • Empathize

  • Agree

  • Partner

Rather than arguing or trying to persuade someone to change, LEAP helps families build trust and work collaboratively toward solutions.


The authors also describe the Harm Reduction approach. Instead of expecting an entire house to be cleaned out, the goal is to reduce immediate safety risks. That may mean clearing pathways, making the bathroom accessible, reducing fire hazards, or ensuring emergency responders can enter the home if needed.


Just as important, the book cautions against one of the biggest mistakes families can make: secretly throwing possessions away.

For someone with a hoarding disorder, that action can destroy trust, increase anxiety, and intensify saving behaviors. Although it may feel like a quick solution, it often makes future help much more difficult because the person no longer feels safe accepting assistance. Progress doesn't always look the way we hope it will—but it can still be meaningful.


Sometimes success isn't a perfectly organized home.

Sometimes success is a clear path to the bathroom.

A functioning kitchen.

A reduced fall risk.

A home that's safer than it was yesterday.


Or simply helping your parents continue living safely in the home they love.

If you're worried about an aging parent's home, remember that change usually happens through trust—not pressure. Whether the issue is decades of accumulation, chronic disorganization, ADHD, or hoarding disorder, understanding what's really happening is the first step.


Focus first on preserving your relationship while reducing safety risks and meeting your parent where they are. The clutter matters, but the relationship matters even more. In my experience, trust—not force—is what opens the door to meaningful and lasting change.


Learn More

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page